Blogs

The Myth of Indestructibility

When most people think of diamonds, they imagine an indestructible gemstone—the hardest natural material on Earth, capable of cutting through anything, and virtually impossible to damage. This perception has been reinforced by centuries of marketing, cultural symbolism, and the famous De Beers slogan "A Diamond is Forever." But here's the surprising truth: Yes, diamonds can break.

While diamonds are indeed the hardest naturally occurring substance known to science, hardness and durability are not the same thing. Understanding this distinction is crucial to appreciating both the remarkable properties of diamonds and their surprising vulnerabilities.

Understanding a Diamond's Crystal Structure

To understand why diamonds can break, we first need to examine their atomic structure at the molecular level.

Diamonds are composed entirely of carbon atoms arranged in an incredibly strong tetrahedral lattice structure. Each carbon atom is covalently bonded to four neighbouring carbon atoms in a three-dimensional network. This arrangement creates the strongest atomic bonds found in nature, which is why diamonds rank 10 on the Mohs hardness scale—the highest possible rating.

This crystalline structure gives diamonds their exceptional properties:

• Extreme hardness - resistance to scratching and abrasion
• High thermal conductivity - diamonds dissipate heat extremely efficiently
• Optical brilliance - the ability to refract and reflect light beautifully
• Chemical inertness - resistance to most acids and bases

However, this same crystal structure also creates a critical weakness: cleavage planes.

Hardness vs. Toughness: The Critical Difference

This is where many people's understandings of diamonds breaks down (pun intended). There's a fundamental difference between hardness and toughness, and diamonds excel at one while being surprisingly poor at the other.

Hardness refers to a material's resistance to scratching, indentation, or abrasion. It's about how difficult it is to permanently deform the surface. Diamonds are unmatched in this category — only another diamond can scratch a diamond.

Toughness (or tenacity), on the other hand, refers to a material's ability to absorb energy and resist fracturing when subjected to impact or stress. It's about how well a material can withstand sudden force without breaking.

Here's the shocking reality: Diamonds have excellent hardness but relatively poor toughness.

To put this in perspective:

• Diamond hardness: 10/10 on the Mohs scale (the highest)
• Diamond toughness: 7.5/10 on the tenacity scale (good, but not exceptional)

Materials like jade or nephrite have lower hardness ratings but are tougher than diamonds because their interlocking crystal structures can absorb impact energy without fracturing. Steel is another example — it can be scratched more easily than diamond, but it won't shatter when struck with a hammer.

Cleavage Planes: Diamond's Achilles' Heel

The key to understanding why diamonds break lies in their cleavage planes — specific directions within the crystal structure where the atomic bonds are relatively weaker.

Diamonds have four perfect cleavage planes that run parallel to the octahedral faces of the crystal. These planes correspond to the {111} crystallographic directions. When force is applied along these planes, the diamond can split cleanly with relatively little effort compared to the force needed to break it in other directions.

This property is both a weakness and a tool:

As a weakness: If a diamond is struck at the right angle along a cleavage plane, it can split or chip, even from a relatively modest impact. This is why diamonds in jewellery can chip if knocked against a hard surface at the wrong angle.

As a tool: Diamond cutters have used this property for centuries to shape rough diamonds. By carefully studying the crystal structure and applying precise force along cleavage planes, skilled craftsmen can split large rough diamonds into smaller pieces or remove unwanted portions. This technique, called "cleaving," was the primary method of shaping diamonds before modern sawing techniques were developed.

Real-World Ways Diamonds Can Break

Now that we understand the science, let's look at practical scenarios where diamonds can be damaged or broken:

1. Direct Impact

Dropping a diamond ring onto a hard surface like concrete or tile, or striking it against a hard object, can cause chipping or fracturing, especially if the impact occurs along a cleavage plane. The prongs or setting may protect the diamond to some extent, but exposed edges and corners are particularly vulnerable.

2. Thermal Shock

Diamonds have excellent thermal conductivity, but sudden extreme temperature changes can cause them to crack. For example, heating a diamond with a torch and then plunging it into cold water can create internal stresses that lead to fracturing. This is rarely a concern in everyday wear but can be an issue during jewellery repair if proper precautions aren't taken.

3. Inclusions and Internal Flaws

Many diamonds contain internal imperfections called inclusions—tiny crystals, fractures, or other materials trapped during formation. These inclusions can create weak points within the diamond. If stress is applied near an inclusion, it can propagate into a larger crack or fracture. This is one reason why clarity (the absence of inclusions) affects not just appearance but also structural integrity.

4. Poor Setting or Mounting

A diamond that's improperly set in jewellery is more vulnerable to damage. If the setting doesn't adequately protect the stone or if it places stress on the diamond, normal wear and tear can eventually cause problems.

5. Intentional Breaking

With the right tools and knowledge, diamonds can be deliberately broken. Diamond cutters use specialised cleaving tools, lasers, or diamond-tipped saws to shape rough stones. Even a simple hammer and chisel, applied correctly along a cleavage plane, can split a diamond.

Historical Examples and Anecdotes

The breakability of diamonds isn't just theoretical — there are numerous documented cases:

The Cullinan Diamond: The largest gem-quality rough diamond ever found (3,106 carats), the Cullinan was cleaved into several pieces in 1908. The master cutter, Joseph Asscher, studied the stone for months before making his cut. Legend has it that he fainted after successfully cleaving the stone due to the immense pressure and relief.

The Hope Diamond: This famous blue diamond has been recut at least once in its history, with material removed to improve its appearance — a process that involves controlled breaking and shaping.

Jeweller Accidents: Professional jewellers occasionally report diamonds chipping or breaking during setting, resizing, or repair work, particularly when heat is applied during soldering operations near the stone.

Laboratory Testing: Materials scientists regularly break diamonds in controlled settings to study their properties, fracture mechanics, and to test the limits of the material.

Protecting Your Diamonds

Understanding that diamonds can break doesn't mean you should be paranoid about wearing diamond jewellery. With reasonable care, diamonds can last for generations. Here are some practical tips:

1. Avoid Hard Impacts: Remove diamond rings when doing activities like weightlifting, rock climbing, or heavy manual labour where the stone might strike hard surfaces.
2. Regular Inspections: Have a jeweller check your settings annually to ensure prongs are secure and the diamond isn't loose.
3. Proper Storage: Store diamond jewellery separately to prevent pieces from scratching each other and use padded jewellery boxes.
4. Professional Cleaning: While diamonds are chemically inert, have them professionally cleaned and inspected rather than using harsh methods at home.
5. Insurance: Consider insuring valuable diamond jewellery against loss, theft, and damage.
6. Choose Protective Settings: Bezel settings offer more protection than prong settings, though they may show less of the stone.

The Bottom Line

So, can diamonds break? Absolutely. Despite being the hardest natural material on Earth, diamonds are not indestructible. Their crystalline structure, while incredibly resistant to scratching, contains cleavage planes that make them vulnerable to fracturing from impact or stress applied in specific directions.

This doesn't diminish the remarkable properties of diamonds or their value as gemstones. Rather, it highlights the importance of understanding the difference between hardness and toughness and the need to treat even the most durable materials with appropriate care.

The next time someone tells you that diamonds are forever, you can smile knowingly and add: "Yes, but only if you don't hit them with a hammer along the cleavage plane."

Key Takeaways:

• ✓ Diamonds are the hardest natural material but have only moderate toughness
• ✓ Cleavage planes make diamonds vulnerable to breaking when struck at certain angles
• ✓ Diamonds can chip, crack, or shatter from impact, thermal shock, or stress
• ✓ Proper care and setting can protect diamonds for generations
• ✓ Hardness (scratch resistance) and toughness (impact resistance) are different properties